Ninja Smoke Bomb Needs Nerfed (and Securing Objectives while Invis is a Game Breaker)

[Hooligantuan]

Title says it all. Capturing an objective, like in Fumigation, while Invisible is not cool even a little bit. There's a reason why this isn't supported in Team Fortress 2 (the only other significant game out there with multiplayer and cloaking): it's game-breakingly wrong.


And getting rolled by an enemy team where 4 of its dudes are running around cloaked sucks, especially when half of them are toting shotguns. Easily the most infuriating match I've ever been in and I should have ragequit it two minutes in. I want to strangle somebody.

You guys need to take a look at your Ninja Smoke Bombs, bad. I am amazed you can secure objectives while invisible. I am amazed you can recover at a recovery station while invisible. It's straight up ridiculous that we can run all around a map holding L2 to go invisible and it'll never drop until we're taken out or let go of L2. I can't believe checking someone with gunfire doesn't affect the quality of the cloak for a few seconds. I can't believe the invisibility drops as fast as it does. I am just about aghast that Ninja Smoke Bmbs have no recharge period like every other gadget. Heck, I can't believe it's a GADGET. I can't believe you don't have to resupply this item - really, I can't believe it's not a Support item.

Ninja Smoke Bomb needs nerfed.

[Bahman]

Dude, you can clearly see the person. Being Invisible creates a distortion effect, thats pretty noticeable, not to mention in order to get the gasblaster you have to be pretty close anyway. Just take a breather and come back to the game later if it really pisses you off. Although i agree with the recharge period thing. Then again Theres a healing tincan option with also very minimal recharge. Its a fast passed game.

[alucidzombie]

yeah i dont know how many times ive been invis capturing an objective only to have someone spot me immediately and kill be before i could go visible. its really not that overpowered, it just requires skill to find the ninjas.
I mean in Fumigation there's only a limited radius around the gasblaster that you can stand in, so if it's contested and you don't see anybody just look around for the effect, and if that fails you can use trap-in-a-boxes or take an automatic weapon and spin around in a circle while firing and laughing maniacally.

[XIBangBang]

Hi you must be New. the Ninja smoke bomb actually is in need of an improvement. good players see them as free kills. try and use smoke bomb if you think it is that good. you will rage even more when you get killed over and over again without the ability to defend yourself.

[Zerl]

Oh look... Another one!

Seriously I wish people would think about things like this before they post QQ threads.

I'm not even going to go into detail as to how to counter them, as you can easily look through the forums and find loads (seriously, LOADS) of posts made by people telling QQers how to counter the NSB.

[Hooligantuan]

I've thought about this rather considerably, Zerl. If you disagree, cool, but I made a rather concise list detailing areas where I believe an imbalance is present.

You also cannot reasonably expect to be prepared for every situation at every point in the game, so it's ridiculous to expect it of anyone else and suggest that everyone merely go out and use a silver bullet counter to the strategy. It's part of making choices in the limited space of a loadout.

But I would love to hear what the counter is to Ninja Smoke Bombs with Wallflower, Body Armor, a Sniffer'd Shotgun, and a Silenced gun. I'd love to hear what the counter is to half a team set up like that, going with either Body Armor or Bear Traps.

(Is it "get good"? Be better than the whole enemy team? Ragequit and re-queue?)

[Hooligantuan]

Dude, you can clearly see the person. Being Invisible creates a distortion effect, thats pretty noticeable, not to mention in order to get the gasblaster you have to be pretty close anyway.

Well, I know there's a distortion effect, but it can (appropriately, mind you) be very difficult to see - it's kinda the point, I know - and around the Gasblaster in particular it's difficult to see due to the particle effects around it. Seeing a distorted Speedy or Nimble can be very difficult, especially at range, and especially at certain poorly lit objectives (objective 2 in the warehouse at the Docks, for instance) and there's a good chance you'll be absolutely screwed if they were toting bear traps and a shotty.

I can't say it's even remotely fair to secure objectives while cloaked and the invisibility effect should flicker significantly under gunfire. Aiming down sight at a distortion, it's even pretty easy to lose the guy in muzzle flash.

[Syxx6]

Title says it all. Capturing an objective, like in Fumigation, while Invisible is not cool even a little bit. There's a reason why this isn't supported in Team Fortress 2 (the only other significant game out there with multiplayer and cloaking): it's game-breakingly wrong.


And getting rolled by an enemy team where 4 of its dudes are running around cloaked sucks, especially when half of them are toting shotguns. Easily the most infuriating match I've ever been in and I should have ragequit it two minutes in. I want to strangle somebody.

You guys need to take a look at your Ninja Smoke Bombs, bad. I am amazed you can secure objectives while invisible. I am amazed you can recover at a recovery station while invisible. It's straight up ridiculous that we can run all around a map holding L2 to go invisible and it'll never drop until we're taken out or let go of L2. I can't believe checking someone with gunfire doesn't affect the quality of the cloak for a few seconds. I can't believe the invisibility drops as fast as it does. I am just about aghast that Ninja Smoke Bmbs have no recharge period like every other gadget. Heck, I can't believe it's a GADGET. I can't believe you don't have to resupply this item - really, I can't believe it's not a Support item.

Ninja Smoke Bomb needs nerfed.

I get killed while cloaked more than I get killed while uncloaked.. its clearly easy to see people that are "invisible" especially if they're standing still capping. You realize there is a 1.5-2sec delay before you can even attack when coming out of stealth right? If someone gets the jump on you while capping which is probably the case the cloaked person is dead for sure. I use NSB exclusively and It's only good from flanking from a distance it does nothing at all if up close to players unless they're complete idiots.

[DDE_Max_Sterling]

You guys need to take a look at your Ninja Smoke Bombs, bad. I am amazed you can secure objectives while invisible. I am amazed you can recover at a recovery station while invisible. It's straight up ridiculous that we can run all around a map holding L2 to go invisible and it'll never drop until we're taken out or let go of L2. I can't believe checking someone with gunfire doesn't affect the quality of the cloak for a few seconds. I can't believe the invisibility drops as fast as it does. I am just about aghast that Ninja Smoke Bmbs have no recharge period like every other gadget. Heck, I can't believe it's a GADGET. I can't believe you don't have to resupply this item - really, I can't believe it's not a Support item.

I can't believe you're too stubborn to throw down motion sensors. If NSB is OP, then so are Motion Sensors... and if Motion Sensors are OP, then so is standing still while in the range of Motion Sensors.

[Freeze_Myzer]

I'm with you bro...I hate the ninja smoke bomb and how its so over used...someone else replied and said "dude u can clearly see them" but IDK what he's talkin bout cause I can't see them unless they are litterally right in front of my face...